David Jonsson vs Damson Idris as Black Panther + Spider-Man Review

Fatal Jay discusses David Jonsson and Damson Idris as the new Black Panther and reviews Spider-Man: Brand New Day.

Ladies and gentlemen, Marvel just gave us two huge topics that have comic-book fans arguing all over the internet.

First, David Jonsson has officially been introduced as the new Black Panther. He will play an adult T’Challa II, also known as Toussaint, the son of T’Challa and Nakia. Ryan Coogler brought him onto the Comic-Con stage alongside Kevin Feige, Letitia Wright and Winston Duke.

Second, Spider-Man: Brand New Day may have finally given us the most comic-book-accurate version of Tom Holland’s Spider-Man.

Let me give you my quick answers before I break everything down.

David Jonsson is a talented actor, but my main problem is not David Jonsson. My problem is Marvel moving past the original T’Challa without giving another actor the chance to continue his story.

And when it comes to Spider-Man?

Yes, Brand New Day may be Tom Holland’s best Spider-Man movie.

It finally stops treating Peter Parker like Iron Man Junior and allows him to become the broke, lonely, struggling and heroic Spider-Man that comic-book readers know.

David Jonsson Is Officially the New Black Panther

Ryan Coogler officially introduced David Jonsson as Marvel’s new Black Panther during the 2026 San Diego Comic-Con presentation.

Jonsson will play T’Challa II, the grown son of the original T’Challa. Black Panther 3 is currently scheduled for December 15, 2028.

First, let me give this brother his respect.

David Jonsson can act.

I have seen enough of his work to know that he can bring real emotion and power to a role. My criticism is not about personally attacking him or pretending that he has no talent. I said during the livestream that he could be a powerful actor and bring some heat to the franchise.

My problem is the direction Marvel has chosen.

This is not T’Challa, son of T’Chaka.

This is his son, Toussaint, who also carries the name T’Challa. That may technically continue the family legacy, but it does not continue the original character’s unfinished story.

Those are two different things.

My Problem Is Not David Jonsson—It Is What Happened to T’Challa

T’Challa is not simply a random person wearing a Black Panther costume.

He is one of the most important characters in Marvel history.

T’Challa first appeared in Fantastic Four #52 in 1966. Marvel has described him as the first Black superhero in the Marvel Universe and a groundbreaking figure in comic-book history.

That history matters.

When Chadwick Boseman appeared in Captain America: Civil War, the world was ready for Black Panther. That entrance is still one of the coldest character introductions in the entire MCU.

Winter Soldier is running. You see that shadow coming. T’Challa leaps over him, lands and immediately looks like a force nobody wants to play with.

That was not simply a cool suit.

That was T’Challa.

He was a king, warrior, scientist, Avenger, diplomat, son, brother and protector. There were decades of stories Marvel could have explored.

Instead, his MCU story ended just as it was truly beginning.

Should Marvel Have Recast the Original T’Challa?

Yes.

I understand why Marvel did not immediately recast the role after Chadwick Boseman passed away. His death affected the cast, fans and the entire entertainment world.

But allowing another actor to continue T’Challa’s story would not have erased Chadwick.

James Bond has been played by multiple actors. Batman has been played by multiple actors. Superman, Spider-Man and the Joker have all been recast.

The character survives because the story is bigger than one performance.

Chadwick Boseman will always be the first live-action MCU T’Challa. Nothing can remove what he accomplished. A new actor would simply have continued the character’s story for another generation.

Instead, Marvel has introduced Shuri as Black Panther and is now moving toward T’Challa’s adult son. Every film risks feeling as though the franchise is starting over with another Panther rather than developing one central hero.

That was one of the biggest concerns in my livestream discussion: Iron Man, Thor and Captain America were allowed to build their legends, while the lore surrounding T’Challa keeps being changed and restarted.

David Jonsson or Damson Idris: Who Looks More Like Black Panther?

Between David Jonsson and Damson Idris, I understand why many fans looked at Damson as the more natural Black Panther choice.

Damson has the physical presence, confidence and action-star look that many people connect with T’Challa. Images discussed during the livestream also caused fans to believe that certain Black Panther designs resembled him.

But let me be completely honest:

My real answer is not David Jonsson or Damson Idris as T’Challa Junior. My first choice would have been a strong actor playing the original T’Challa.

If Marvel insisted on using Toussaint, I would still want an actor who immediately looks believable as a warrior king. David may transform his body, change his movement and completely surprise everybody once we see him inside the suit.

Hollywood magic can do a lot.

However, Marvel must sell the audience on him as more than a talented dramatic actor. He has to look like somebody who can command Wakanda, face Doctor Doom, fight alongside the Avengers and stand in a room with the most powerful characters in the MCU.

That is a heavy responsibility.

Was Damson Idris Rejected Because of Michael B. Jordan and Lori Harvey?

Now we have reached the EXPOSED part of the conversation.

During the livestream, I brought up a theory involving Damson Idris, Michael B. Jordan, Lori Harvey and Ryan Coogler.

The theory suggests that personal history involving Michael B. Jordan and Lori Harvey could have made casting Damson Idris uncomfortable, particularly if Michael B. Jordan returns as Killmonger or appears in the Ancestral Plane.

Let me be crystal clear:

This is a fan theory. It is not a confirmed fact.

I found no reliable public evidence proving that Michael B. Jordan influenced the casting decision, that Ryan Coogler rejected Damson Idris for personal reasons or that Lori Harvey had anything to do with Marvel choosing David Jonsson.

Damson Idris was widely discussed by fans as a possible Black Panther, but Marvel officially selected David Jonsson as T’Challa’s adult son.

The livestream theory came from trying to explain why the casting seemed to change direction after fans connected Damson to Black Panther imagery.

It is entertaining speculation, but I would never tell you that speculation is proof.

Marvel may have simply believed David Jonsson was the better actor for the specific version of Toussaint Ryan Coogler wanted to create.

Until somebody directly involved explains the decision, we do not know.

Why Not Bring Back T’Challa Through the Multiverse?

The MCU is currently dealing with alternate universes, timelines, variants and Secret Wars.

Marvel can bring back different versions of almost anybody.

So, if an adult Toussaint can appear through a time jump or multiverse storyline, why is it impossible to introduce another version of the original T’Challa?

You mean to tell me that every T’Challa in every universe is gone?

Come on, Marvel.

A variant would allow Marvel to preserve Chadwick Boseman’s version while introducing another T’Challa with his own history. That character could be a king who lost his Wakanda, a warrior whose family was destroyed or a Panther pulled into the main MCU by an incursion.

There are countless ways to do it respectfully.

David Jonsson could still become T’Challa II later. There is room for both characters.

Marvel does not have to erase a father’s story to make room for his son.

Spider-Man: Brand New Day Spoiler Review

Now let us get into Spider-Man: Brand New Day.

Major spoilers begin here.

The movie takes place after the world forgets Peter Parker. Peter is living alone and fighting crime full-time while MJ and Ned continue their lives without remembering him.

The pressure begins causing a dangerous physical evolution that Peter struggles to control. At the same time, an unseen enemy creates a new threat across New York. Marvel and Sony’s official descriptions confirm Peter’s isolation, changing powers and the invisible threat at the center of the story.

Ladies and gentlemen, this movie was off the hook.

This is the Tom Holland Spider-Man movie I have been waiting to see.

Brand New Day Finally Stops Treating Peter Like Iron Man Junior

One of my biggest problems with the earlier Tom Holland movies was how dependent Peter felt on Tony Stark.

Peter had Stark technology, Stark suits, Stark drones, Stark problems and villains connected to Stark’s decisions.

Sometimes it felt like we were watching Iron Boy instead of Spider-Man.

That is gone now.

There is no Mr. Stark coming to save Peter.

Aunt May is gone. MJ does not remember him. Ned does not remember him. Peter has nobody to run to when his life begins falling apart.

He is completely alone.

And that is where Peter Parker becomes Spider-Man.

This Is the Most Comic-Book-Accurate Tom Holland Spider-Man

Spider-Man is a hero, but Peter Parker’s personal life is usually a complete mess.

He saves the city and then goes home broke.

He defeats a supervillain and then misses an important date.

He protects everybody around him while losing the people closest to him.

That struggle is why millions of people connect with him.

The livestream discussion kept coming back to Peter watching MJ and Ned live their lives while knowing he could not be part of them. It also focused on how Peter finally had to face his loneliness and accept both the good and aggressive sides of himself.

That is Spider-Man all day.

He is not interesting because everything works out for him. He is interesting because almost nothing works out, yet he still puts the mask back on.

The MJ Story Does Not Take the Easy Way Out

I respected the movie for not magically breaking the spell through the power of love.

MJ does not suddenly look into Peter’s eyes and remember their entire relationship.

She barely knows him.

When she finds Peter’s letter, the movie becomes quiet and allows both characters to sit inside that uncomfortable moment.

Peter wants his old life back, but MJ did not choose to be part of it because she cannot remember making that choice.

That creates real emotional stakes.

The movie understands that Peter cannot simply take what he wants because he misses her. He has to respect the life MJ now has.

That hurts, but Peter Parker stories are supposed to hurt sometimes.

Punisher Is Exactly Who Punisher Should Be

The Punisher was dope in this movie.

Jon Bernthal’s Frank Castle does not become a softened, family-friendly version of the character. He is aggressive, foul-mouthed, dangerous and willing to enter fights that a normal human being should avoid.

Watching Punisher go at Hulk gave me chills.

Does shooting Hulk make much logical sense?

Not really. Hulk can eat those bullets like breakfast.

But on a pure comic-book level, watching Frank Castle stand his ground against a giant green monster was 100% fire.

Jon Bernthal and Mark Ruffalo are both officially part of the movie’s cast, and the livestream highlighted Punisher and Spider-Man fighting Hulk as one of its biggest crowd-pleasing sequences.

Spider-Man vs. Savage Hulk Is One of the Best MCU Fights

This is not the calm Hulk sitting in a diner taking selfies.

We get Savage Hulk.

The madder he becomes, the larger, stronger and more dangerous he gets. You can see Bruce Banner trying to hold the rage back before Hulk completely takes over.

When Hulk starts throwing Spider-Man around, I honestly thought Peter was finished.

The hits felt vicious.

What made the scene work was that Peter did not try to beat Hulk through raw strength. He used his intelligence. He strategically placed webbing around Hulk’s body and the environment to slow him down.

That is how Spider-Man should fight somebody stronger than him.

Peter Parker is one of Marvel’s smartest heroes. He survives because he thinks while he fights. The transcript specifically praised the way Peter used his webbing strategically instead of trying to overpower Hulk.

Sadie Sink as Jean Grey Was a Bold Choice

The movie eventually reveals Sadie Sink’s character as Jean Grey.

Before the reveal, the invisible, body-jumping threat creates a horror-style mystery. You never know who is being controlled or where the danger will come from next.

Jean is presented as dangerous, but I did not see her as a simple evil villain.

Peter shares her mind and realizes she is hurt, angry and misguided. Her actions are wrong, but he understands that placing her inside another laboratory will only continue the cycle that created the problem.

Sadie Sink gives Jean pain, rage and vulnerability. The character’s arrival also creates a major connection between Spider-Man and the MCU’s future X-Men stories.

The livestream compared the body-jumping mystery to Fallen and praised the decision to give Jean a darker side without reducing her to a basic villain.

Peter’s Mutation Makes His Internal Struggle Physical

Peter’s changing body is not simply a new power-up designed to sell toys.

The mutation represents everything he has been holding inside.

He has lost May, MJ, Ned and his entire identity. He continues fighting every day without allowing himself to properly deal with that pain.

Eventually, the pressure has to come out.

Peter must accept that he is not only the friendly neighborhood Spider-Man. He also has anger, fear and aggression inside him.

The lesson is not that Peter should allow his darkness to control him. The lesson is that pretending it does not exist makes it more dangerous.

Once Peter accepts both sides of himself, he gains control rather than losing it.

That gave the action an emotional purpose.

New York Finally Feels Like Part of Spider-Man’s World

New York looks incredible in this movie.

The web-swinging scenes are some of the strongest we have received from Tom Holland’s Spider-Man. Peter moves through the streets and between buildings in a way that feels straight out of the comics.

New York is not just a background.

It is part of the character.

Spider-Man belongs inside crowded streets, apartments, rooftops, alleys and skyscrapers. The livestream praised the movie for making the city feel alive and for delivering some of Holland’s best web-swinging sequences.

Is Brand New Day Tom Holland’s Best Spider-Man Movie?

For me, yes.

No Way Home delivered powerful nostalgia and emotional moments. Seeing Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield return was legendary.

But Brand New Day is the better Peter Parker story.

It gives Tom Holland a movie that does not depend on Iron Man, Doctor Strange or alternate Spider-Men to carry it.

Peter carries this one.

He is lonely. He is broke. His powers are changing. The woman he loves does not remember him. Hulk nearly destroys him. Jean Grey invades minds. Punisher brings chaos everywhere he goes.

And Peter still gets back up.

That is why this may be my favorite Tom Holland Spider-Man movie. It is the closest his movies have come to capturing the hero from the classic comics.

My Final Verdict

David Jonsson deserves a fair opportunity to prove himself as the new Black Panther.

He is talented, and I am not rooting for him to fail.

However, I still believe Marvel should have recast T’Challa, son of T’Chaka, and allowed his unfinished story to continue. Between David Jonsson and Damson Idris, Damson may have the stronger traditional Black Panther presence—but my true choice remains a recast original T’Challa.

As for the theory involving Michael B. Jordan and Lori Harvey, it is entertaining internet speculation and nothing more. There is no proof that anyone’s personal relationship affected Marvel’s casting decision.

And Spider-Man: Brand New Day?

That movie is pure fire.

It gives us the real Peter Parker, a dangerous Savage Hulk, a comic-accurate Punisher, a surprisingly deep Jean Grey storyline and the emotional consequences that previous movies set up.

My final Brand New Day rating: 9 out of 10.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is David Jonsson the new Black Panther?

Yes. David Jonsson has officially been cast as the new Black Panther and will play the adult T’Challa II, son of T’Challa and Nakia, in Black Panther 3.

Is Damson Idris playing Black Panther?

No. Damson Idris was a popular fan choice, but David Jonsson received the role.

Did Michael B. Jordan stop Damson Idris from becoming Black Panther?

There is no confirmed evidence that Michael B. Jordan influenced Marvel’s casting decision. That idea is a fan theory, not an established fact.

Should Marvel recast T’Challa?

In my opinion, yes. Recasting T’Challa would allow Marvel to continue the original character’s comic-book story while permanently honoring Chadwick Boseman as the actor who first brought him to life in the MCU.

Is Spider-Man: Brand New Day Tom Holland’s best Spider-Man movie?

In my opinion, it is. The film gives Peter a more independent, emotionally difficult and comic-accurate story than his previous solo movies.

Are Hulk and Punisher in Spider-Man: Brand New Day?

Yes. Mark Ruffalo returns as Bruce Banner and Hulk, while Jon Bernthal appears as Frank Castle, also known as Punisher.

Who does Sadie Sink play in Brand New Day?

Sadie Sink plays Jean Grey, connecting Spider-Man’s story to the MCU’s developing mutant and X-Men storylines.


The Fatal Jay Insider

Get My Exclusive Video

2026 Marvel & DC:

Cooked or Cooking? FREE

Related Post